Christian McCaffrey
SF vs. SEAFloor13.8
Median17.9
Ceiling26.0
Recent PPG: 16.5
Recent volume: 20.0
Snap share: 79%
Availability: No current-week designation
Week 5 lineup decision · updated Oct 7, 2026, 3:25 PM EDT
Christian McCaffrey or Jonathan Taylor: who should I start?
Start Jonathan Taylor over Christian McCaffrey in Week 5. The Half PPR projection is 19.9 to 17.9.
The lean blends recorded scoring, recent workload, opponent positional defense and only same-week listed availability. Recheck the official inactive list before kickoff.
SF vs. SEAOpen player file →
Jonathan Taylor
IND vs. PITFloor10.4
Median19.9
Ceiling23.9
Recent PPG: 20.3
Recent volume: 25.0
Snap share: 78%
Availability: No current-week designation
Scoring changes the call
4 points per passing TDWeek 5 projection by format.
Standard
Start Jonathan Taylor
3.1-point gapHigh confidence
Other option
Christian McCaffrey
SF vs. SEA- Floor
- 11.6
- Projection
- 15.5
- Ceiling
- 23.6
Recommended start
Jonathan Taylor
IND vs. PIT- Floor
- 9.1
- Projection
- 18.6
- Ceiling
- 22.3
Half PPR
Start Jonathan Taylor
2.0-point gapHigh confidence
Other option
Christian McCaffrey
SF vs. SEA- Floor
- 13.8
- Projection
- 17.9
- Ceiling
- 26.0
Recommended start
Jonathan Taylor
IND vs. PIT- Floor
- 10.4
- Projection
- 19.9
- Ceiling
- 23.9
PPR
Start Jonathan Taylor — close call
0.9-point gapHigh confidence
Other option
Christian McCaffrey
SF vs. SEA- Floor
- 15.5
- Projection
- 20.4
- Ceiling
- 28.5
Recommended start
Jonathan Taylor
IND vs. PIT- Floor
- 10.7
- Projection
- 21.3
- Ceiling
- 25.7
Floor and ceiling show the lower and upper ends of the player's recent scoring range. The projection is the middle estimate after current role, matchup, and same-week availability are applied.
Why the model leans this way
Role first. Matchup second. Availability always visible.
Two relevant running-back options in a similar weekly range, compared through touches, receiving work, matchup and current availability.
Christian McCaffrey: recent role is near baseline, and the matchup is tougher. Jonathan Taylor: recent role is near baseline, and the matchup is tougher.
Availability adjustments apply only when the source contains a Week 5 report. Older designations remain visible in the injury archive but do not reduce this projection.
Week 4 final result
Jonathan Taylor scored more. The pregame lean was right.
Christian McCaffrey: 14.5 Half PPR · Jonathan Taylor: 22.2 Half PPR.