Start with comparable evidence.
Both players use the same release, format, league size, and composite scale. Rank is context, while the percentage gap measures the trade difference.
110 live decisions // updated October 7, 2026
Player vs. player,with the settings on.
Compare 132 players across dynasty Superflex, dynasty 1QB, tight end premium, and redraft—then measure the exact effect of standard, half-PPR, full-PPR, or six-point passing touchdowns. Every answer updates from the same validated market release.
Change the scoring, not the story.
The scoring model uses observed per-game profiles and subtracts same-position replacement. Players do not receive generic PPR or passing-TD bumps.
A market answer is not a forecast.
Injuries, lineup need, manager preference, and future outcomes remain outside the score. Close values should be treated as a tier, not false precision.
Curated head-to-head index
110 decisions worth measuring.
Matchups were selected from meaningful current value neighborhoods, not generated as every possible name combination. Every pairing must present a real format, scoring, timeline, or roster-construction decision.
QB comparisons
21 matchups
Josh Allen
Drake MayeJosh Allenvs.Drake Maye
999 · #1#24 · 590
Open the evidence →
Lamar Jackson
Caleb WilliamsLamar Jacksonvs.Caleb Williams
696 · #11#10 · 696
Open the evidence →
Jayden Daniels
Joe BurrowJayden Danielsvs.Joe Burrow
532 · #29#17 · 628
Open the evidence →
Justin Herbert
Patrick MahomesJustin Herbertvs.Patrick Mahomes
437 · #50#21 · 598
Open the evidence →
Jalen Hurts
Trevor LawrenceJalen Hurtsvs.Trevor Lawrence
494 · #33#23 · 592
Open the evidence →
Bo Nix
Brock PurdyBo Nixvs.Brock Purdy
457 · #44#18 · 611
Open the evidence →
Baker Mayfield
Jared GoffBaker Mayfieldvs.Jared Goff
284 · #96#61 · 392
Open the evidence →
Cam Ward
C.J. StroudCam Wardvs.C.J. Stroud
288 · #93#66 · 378
Open the evidence →
Dak Prescott
Jordan LoveDak Prescottvs.Jordan Love
466 · #41#56 · 416
Open the evidence →
Geno Smith
Jacoby BrissettGeno Smithvs.Jacoby Brissett
185 · #169#161 · 191
Open the evidence →
Aaron Rodgers
Kirk CousinsAaron Rodgersvs.Kirk Cousins
147 · #212#142 · 206
Open the evidence →Patrick MahomesJalen HurtsPatrick Mahomesvs.Jalen Hurts
598 · #21#33 · 494
Open the evidence →Joe BurrowLamar JacksonJoe Burrowvs.Lamar Jackson
628 · #17#11 · 696
Open the evidence →Caleb WilliamsJayden DanielsCaleb Williamsvs.Jayden Daniels
696 · #10#29 · 532
Open the evidence →Drake MayeLamar JacksonDrake Mayevs.Lamar Jackson
590 · #24#11 · 696
Open the evidence →C.J. Stroud
Kyler MurrayC.J. Stroudvs.Kyler Murray
378 · #66#102 · 264
Open the evidence →
Tyler ShoughCam WardTyler Shoughvs.Cam Ward
505 · #32#93 · 288
Open the evidence →
Bryce Young
Sam DarnoldBryce Youngvs.Sam Darnold
478 · #39#79 · 351
Open the evidence →
Matthew StaffordDak PrescottMatthew Staffordvs.Dak Prescott
287 · #94#41 · 466
Open the evidence →Joe BurrowCaleb WilliamsJoe Burrowvs.Caleb Williams
628 · #17#10 · 696
Open the evidence →Kyler MurraySam DarnoldKyler Murrayvs.Sam Darnold
264 · #102#79 · 351
Open the evidence →RB comparisons
34 matchups
Bijan Robinson
Jahmyr GibbsBijan Robinsonvs.Jahmyr Gibbs
966 · #3#2 · 976
Open the evidence →
Ashton Jeanty
Omarion HamptonAshton Jeantyvs.Omarion Hampton
663 · #14#45 · 455
Open the evidence →
James Cook
Kenneth WalkerJames Cookvs.Kenneth Walker
569 · #26#13 · 676
Open the evidence →
Christian McCaffrey
Chase BrownChristian McCaffreyvs.Chase Brown
483 · #36#34 · 493
Open the evidence →
Breece Hall
Saquon BarkleyBreece Hallvs.Saquon Barkley
437 · #49#69 · 368
Open the evidence →
David Montgomery
Josh JacobsDavid Montgomeryvs.Josh Jacobs
240 · #116#123 · 228
Open the evidence →
Rhamondre Stevenson
Jaylen WarrenRhamondre Stevensonvs.Jaylen Warren
225 · #126#91 · 292
Open the evidence →
Zach Charbonnet
Blake CorumZach Charbonnetvs.Blake Corum
250 · #110#109 · 251
Open the evidence →
Chuba Hubbard
J.K. DobbinsChuba Hubbardvs.J.K. Dobbins
342 · #81#180 · 177
Open the evidence →
Kyle Monangai
Tyler AllgeierKyle Monangaivs.Tyler Allgeier
290 · #92#173 · 183
Open the evidence →
Tony Pollard
Kenny GainwellTony Pollardvs.Kenny Gainwell
195 · #157#187 · 170
Open the evidence →Jordan Mason
Rachaad WhiteJordan Masonvs.Rachaad White
188 · #164#185 · 172
Open the evidence →Chris RodriguezBrian RobinsonChris Rodriguezvs.Brian Robinson
150 · #208#168 · 187
Open the evidence →
Braelon Allen
Keaton MitchellBraelon Allenvs.Keaton Mitchell
219 · #130#159 · 193
Open the evidence →Aaron Jones
Alvin KamaraAaron Jonesvs.Alvin Kamara
198 · #149#199 · 156
Open the evidence →Braelon Allen
Tank BigsbyBraelon Allenvs.Tank Bigsby
219 · #130#191 · 168
Open the evidence →Keaton Mitchell
Tyjae SpearsKeaton Mitchellvs.Tyjae Spears
193 · #159#200 · 156
Open the evidence →Aaron JonesBrian RobinsonAaron Jonesvs.Brian Robinson
198 · #149#168 · 187
Open the evidence →
Quinshon JudkinsBreece HallQuinshon Judkinsvs.Breece Hall
402 · #59#49 · 437
Open the evidence →
Javonte Williams
Kyren WilliamsJavonte Williamsvs.Kyren Williams
423 · #53#43 · 463
Open the evidence →
Derrick HenrySaquon BarkleyDerrick Henryvs.Saquon Barkley
422 · #54#69 · 368
Open the evidence →Derrick HenryChristian McCaffreyDerrick Henryvs.Christian McCaffrey
422 · #54#36 · 483
Open the evidence →
Cam SkatteboBucky IrvingCam Skattebovs.Bucky Irving
366 · #70#67 · 375
Open the evidence →Bucky Irving
Travis EtienneBucky Irvingvs.Travis Etienne
375 · #67#104 · 263
Open the evidence →Travis Etienne
TreVeyon HendersonTravis Etiennevs.TreVeyon Henderson
263 · #104#76 · 358
Open the evidence →
D'Andre SwiftJosh JacobsD'Andre Swiftvs.Josh Jacobs
352 · #78#123 · 228
Open the evidence →
RJ HarveyBhayshul TutenRJ Harveyvs.Bhayshul Tuten
245 · #112#62 · 390
Open the evidence →Ashton JeantyBijan RobinsonAshton Jeantyvs.Bijan Robinson
663 · #14#3 · 966
Open the evidence →Jahmyr GibbsAshton JeantyJahmyr Gibbsvs.Ashton Jeanty
976 · #2#14 · 663
Open the evidence →Chase BrownKenneth WalkerChase Brownvs.Kenneth Walker
493 · #34#13 · 676
Open the evidence →Tank BigsbyBrian RobinsonTank Bigsbyvs.Brian Robinson
168 · #191#168 · 187
Open the evidence →Aaron JonesBraelon AllenAaron Jonesvs.Braelon Allen
198 · #149#130 · 219
Open the evidence →Blake CorumJaylen WarrenBlake Corumvs.Jaylen Warren
251 · #109#91 · 292
Open the evidence →Bucky IrvingJavonte WilliamsBucky Irvingvs.Javonte Williams
375 · #67#53 · 423
Open the evidence →WR comparisons
37 matchups
Ja'Marr Chase
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaJa'Marr Chasevs.Jaxon Smith-Njigba
848 · #5#4 · 965
Open the evidence →
Puka Nacua
Amon-Ra St. BrownPuka Nacuavs.Amon-Ra St. Brown
735 · #8#7 · 741
Open the evidence →
Justin Jefferson
Malik NabersJustin Jeffersonvs.Malik Nabers
643 · #15#22 · 595
Open the evidence →
CeeDee Lamb
Drake LondonCeeDee Lambvs.Drake London
701 · #9#20 · 607
Open the evidence →
Tetairoa McMillan
Emeka EgbukaTetairoa McMillanvs.Emeka Egbuka
563 · #27#57 · 413
Open the evidence →
George Pickens
Chris OlaveGeorge Pickensvs.Chris Olave
487 · #35#25 · 583
Open the evidence →
Nico Collins
Garrett WilsonNico Collinsvs.Garrett Wilson
523 · #30#31 · 514
Open the evidence →
Ladd McConkey
DeVonta SmithLadd McConkeyvs.DeVonta Smith
402 · #60#48 · 440
Open the evidence →
Davante AdamsMike EvansDavante Adamsvs.Mike Evans
306 · #90#113 · 242
Open the evidence →
Xavier Worthy
Quentin JohnstonXavier Worthyvs.Quentin Johnston
225 · #125#167 · 187
Open the evidence →
Courtland Sutton
Stefon DiggsCourtland Suttonvs.Stefon Diggs
174 · #183#154 · 196
Open the evidence →
Jalen Coker
Rashid ShaheedJalen Cokervs.Rashid Shaheed
341 · #82#195 · 159
Open the evidence →
Deebo SamuelStefon DiggsDeebo Samuelvs.Stefon Diggs
206 · #144#154 · 196
Open the evidence →
Malik Washington
Dontayvion WicksMalik Washingtonvs.Dontayvion Wicks
187 · #166#141 · 207
Open the evidence →
Tank DellDontayvion WicksTank Dellvs.Dontayvion Wicks
148 · #211#141 · 207
Open the evidence →
Rashee Rice
Zay FlowersRashee Ricevs.Zay Flowers
365 · #71#28 · 546
Open the evidence →Zay Flowers
Luther BurdenZay Flowersvs.Luther Burden
546 · #28#55 · 417
Open the evidence →
A.J. Brown
Jaylen WaddleA.J. Brownvs.Jaylen Waddle
358 · #75#80 · 351
Open the evidence →
Tee Higgins
Rome OdunzeTee Higginsvs.Rome Odunze
423 · #52#86 · 330
Open the evidence →
Marvin Harrison Jr
Jameson WilliamsMarvin Harrison Jrvs.Jameson Williams
263 · #103#87 · 321
Open the evidence →
Brian ThomasParker WashingtonBrian Thomasvs.Parker Washington
260 · #105#42 · 465
Open the evidence →
Matthew GoldenJordan AddisonMatthew Goldenvs.Jordan Addison
390 · #63#101 · 269
Open the evidence →
Alec PierceJosh DownsAlec Piercevs.Josh Downs
251 · #108#100 · 270
Open the evidence →Puka NacuaJustin JeffersonPuka Nacuavs.Justin Jefferson
735 · #8#15 · 643
Open the evidence →CeeDee LambMalik NabersCeeDee Lambvs.Malik Nabers
701 · #9#22 · 595
Open the evidence →Drake LondonGeorge PickensDrake Londonvs.George Pickens
607 · #20#35 · 487
Open the evidence →Nico CollinsTetairoa McMillanNico Collinsvs.Tetairoa McMillan
523 · #30#27 · 563
Open the evidence →Chris OlaveEmeka EgbukaChris Olavevs.Emeka Egbuka
583 · #25#57 · 413
Open the evidence →Puka NacuaJaxon Smith-NjigbaPuka Nacuavs.Jaxon Smith-Njigba
735 · #8#4 · 965
Open the evidence →DeVonta SmithZay FlowersDeVonta Smithvs.Zay Flowers
440 · #48#28 · 546
Open the evidence →Jaylen WaddleTee HigginsJaylen Waddlevs.Tee Higgins
351 · #80#52 · 423
Open the evidence →Parker WashingtonJameson WilliamsParker Washingtonvs.Jameson Williams
465 · #42#87 · 321
Open the evidence →
Adonai MitchellMalik WashingtonAdonai Mitchellvs.Malik Washington
208 · #139#166 · 187
Open the evidence →Deebo Samuel
Tre TuckerDeebo Samuelvs.Tre Tucker
206 · #144#170 · 185
Open the evidence →Nico CollinsChris OlaveNico Collinsvs.Chris Olave
523 · #30#25 · 583
Open the evidence →Ladd McConkeyEmeka EgbukaLadd McConkeyvs.Emeka Egbuka
402 · #60#57 · 413
Open the evidence →Rome OdunzeMarvin Harrison JrRome Odunzevs.Marvin Harrison Jr
330 · #86#103 · 263
Open the evidence →TE comparisons
18 matchups
Brock Bowers
Trey McBrideBrock Bowersvs.Trey McBride
770 · #6#12 · 686
Open the evidence →
Colston Loveland
Tyler WarrenColston Lovelandvs.Tyler Warren
443 · #46#38 · 479
Open the evidence →
Tucker Kraft
Harold FanninTucker Kraftvs.Harold Fannin
362 · #72#64 · 387
Open the evidence →
Sam LaPorta
Kyle PittsSam LaPortavs.Kyle Pitts
356 · #77#115 · 241
Open the evidence →
Dalton Kincaid
George KittleDalton Kincaidvs.George Kittle
331 · #85#89 · 308
Open the evidence →Isaiah LikelyKyle PittsIsaiah Likelyvs.Kyle Pitts
286 · #95#115 · 241
Open the evidence →
Jake FergusonDalton KincaidJake Fergusonvs.Dalton Kincaid
218 · #131#85 · 331
Open the evidence →Jake Ferguson
Dallas GoedertJake Fergusonvs.Dallas Goedert
218 · #131#171 · 184
Open the evidence →Brenton Strange
AJ BarnerBrenton Strangevs.AJ Barner
204 · #146#176 · 182
Open the evidence →
Juwan JohnsonJake FergusonJuwan Johnsonvs.Jake Ferguson
232 · #122#131 · 218
Open the evidence →Michael MayerAJ BarnerMichael Mayervs.AJ Barner
183 · #174#176 · 182
Open the evidence →George KittleSam LaPortaGeorge Kittlevs.Sam LaPorta
308 · #89#77 · 356
Open the evidence →Dalton KincaidKyle PittsDalton Kincaidvs.Kyle Pitts
331 · #85#115 · 241
Open the evidence →Tyler WarrenSam LaPortaTyler Warrenvs.Sam LaPorta
479 · #38#77 · 356
Open the evidence →Sam LaPortaHarold FanninSam LaPortavs.Harold Fannin
356 · #77#64 · 387
Open the evidence →Tucker KraftKyle PittsTucker Kraftvs.Kyle Pitts
362 · #72#115 · 241
Open the evidence →Dallas GoedertJuwan JohnsonDallas Goedertvs.Juwan Johnson
184 · #171#122 · 232
Open the evidence →Tucker KraftSam LaPortaTucker Kraftvs.Sam LaPorta
362 · #72#77 · 356
Open the evidence →How to read a close result
A tier is an answer.
If the value gap is less than roughly five percent and stays small across formats, the evidence does not support demanding a large add. Choose for roster need, timeline, and your own risk tolerance. The calculator remains useful for balancing a full package.
Audit the model →Plain-language answers
Comparison FAQ
How should I compare two dynasty players?
Start with the dynasty market that matches your quarterback format, compare the value gap as a percentage rather than rank alone, and then check the scoring-specific table. A small gap means the players are trade peers; it does not create a precise required add.
Can PPR scoring change which player is worth more?
Yes. Fantasy Trade Target recalculates each player from an observed per-game scoring profile and compares the change with same-position replacement. That can widen, narrow, or occasionally reverse a baseline value gap.
Do six-point passing touchdowns change every quarterback equally?
No. The model uses each quarterback’s observed passing touchdown rate and subtracts the change for a replacement-level quarterback. It does not apply the same blanket multiplier to every QB.
Does the higher-ranked player always win the comparison?
No. The higher current market value is the baseline answer, but 1QB scarcity, redraft horizon, reception scoring, and tight end premium can change the gap. Roster construction and risk preference still sit outside the model.