Free. No login. No nonsense.
93 live decisions // updated November 13, 2026

Player vs. player,with the settings on.

Compare 119 players across dynasty Superflex, dynasty 1QB, tight end premium, and redraft—then measure the exact effect of standard, half-PPR, full-PPR, or six-point passing touchdowns. Every answer updates from the same validated market release.

01 // Same market

Start with comparable evidence.

Both players use the same release, format, league size, and composite scale. Rank is context, while the percentage gap measures the trade difference.

02 // Player-level math

Change the scoring, not the story.

The scoring model uses observed per-game profiles and subtracts same-position replacement. Players do not receive generic PPR or passing-TD bumps.

03 // Honest boundary

A market answer is not a forecast.

Injuries, lineup need, manager preference, and future outcomes remain outside the score. Close values should be treated as a tier, not false precision.

Curated head-to-head index

93 decisions worth measuring.

Matchups were selected from meaningful current value neighborhoods, not generated as every possible name combination. Every pairing must present a real format, scoring, timeline, or roster-construction decision.

QB comparisons

16 matchups
Josh AllenDrake Maye
Current Superflex gap // 269

Josh Allenvs.Drake Maye

999 · #1#9 · 730
Open the evidence →
Jayden DanielsJoe Burrow
Current Superflex gap // 151

Jayden Danielsvs.Joe Burrow

578 · #21#10 · 729
Open the evidence →
Justin HerbertPatrick Mahomes
Current Superflex gap // 145

Justin Herbertvs.Patrick Mahomes

401 · #59#25 · 546
Open the evidence →
Bo NixBrock Purdy
Current Superflex gap // 224

Bo Nixvs.Brock Purdy

422 · #55#16 · 646
Open the evidence →
Baker MayfieldJared Goff
Current Superflex gap // 150

Baker Mayfieldvs.Jared Goff

273 · #100#54 · 423
Open the evidence →
Cam WardC.J. Stroud
Current Superflex gap // 216

Cam Wardvs.C.J. Stroud

301 · #92#34 · 517
Open the evidence →
Dak PrescottJordan Love
Current Superflex gap // 159

Dak Prescottvs.Jordan Love

426 · #53#19 · 585
Open the evidence →
Geno SmithJacoby Brissett
Current Superflex gap // 14

Geno Smithvs.Jacoby Brissett

189 · #166#188 · 175
Open the evidence →
Aaron RodgersKirk Cousins
Current Superflex gap // 76

Aaron Rodgersvs.Kirk Cousins

177 · #186#114 · 253
Open the evidence →
Caleb WilliamsJayden Daniels
Current Superflex gap // 193

Caleb Williamsvs.Jayden Daniels

771 · #7#21 · 578
Open the evidence →
C.J. StroudKyler Murray
Current Superflex gap // 331

C.J. Stroudvs.Kyler Murray

517 · #34#171 · 186
Open the evidence →
Tyler ShoughCam Ward
Current Superflex gap // 137

Tyler Shoughvs.Cam Ward

438 · #50#92 · 301
Open the evidence →
Bryce YoungSam Darnold
Current Superflex gap // 154

Bryce Youngvs.Sam Darnold

440 · #48#94 · 286
Open the evidence →
Matthew StaffordDak Prescott
Current Superflex gap // 159

Matthew Staffordvs.Dak Prescott

267 · #104#53 · 426
Open the evidence →
Joe BurrowCaleb Williams
Current Superflex gap // 42

Joe Burrowvs.Caleb Williams

729 · #10#7 · 771
Open the evidence →
Kyler MurraySam Darnold
Current Superflex gap // 100

Kyler Murrayvs.Sam Darnold

186 · #171#94 · 286
Open the evidence →

RB comparisons

30 matchups
Bijan RobinsonJahmyr Gibbs
Current Superflex gap // 69

Bijan Robinsonvs.Jahmyr Gibbs

916 · #4#2 · 985
Open the evidence →
Ashton JeantyOmarion Hampton
Current Superflex gap // 169

Ashton Jeantyvs.Omarion Hampton

510 · #36#80 · 341
Open the evidence →
James CookKenneth Walker
Current Superflex gap // 133

James Cookvs.Kenneth Walker

568 · #23#12 · 701
Open the evidence →
Christian McCaffreyChase Brown
Current Superflex gap // 119

Christian McCaffreyvs.Chase Brown

491 · #38#72 · 372
Open the evidence →
Breece HallSaquon Barkley
Current Superflex gap // 104

Breece Hallvs.Saquon Barkley

411 · #57#88 · 307
Open the evidence →
David MontgomeryJosh Jacobs
Current Superflex gap // 63

David Montgomeryvs.Josh Jacobs

196 · #157#107 · 259
Open the evidence →
Rhamondre StevensonJaylen Warren
Current Superflex gap // 148

Rhamondre Stevensonvs.Jaylen Warren

245 · #119#62 · 393
Open the evidence →
Zach CharbonnetBlake Corum
Current Superflex gap // 46

Zach Charbonnetvs.Blake Corum

272 · #101#86 · 318
Open the evidence →
Chuba HubbardJ.K. Dobbins
Current Superflex gap // 230

Chuba Hubbardvs.J.K. Dobbins

390 · #64#202 · 160
Open the evidence →
MarShawn LloydJonathon Brooks
Current Superflex gap // 66

MarShawn Lloydvs.Jonathon Brooks

129 · #231#158 · 195
Open the evidence →
Kyle MonangaiTyler Allgeier
Current Superflex gap // 70

Kyle Monangaivs.Tyler Allgeier

279 · #95#141 · 209
Open the evidence →
Tony PollardKenny Gainwell
Current Superflex gap // 65

Tony Pollardvs.Kenny Gainwell

249 · #116#176 · 184
Open the evidence →
Jordan MasonRachaad White
Current Superflex gap // 4

Jordan Masonvs.Rachaad White

189 · #167#162 · 193
Open the evidence →
Dylan SampsonRachaad White
Current Superflex gap // 6

Dylan Sampsonvs.Rachaad White

199 · #153#162 · 193
Open the evidence →
Aaron JonesAlvin Kamara
Current Superflex gap // 34

Aaron Jonesvs.Alvin Kamara

168 · #195#227 · 134
Open the evidence →
Quinshon JudkinsBreece Hall
Current Superflex gap // 52

Quinshon Judkinsvs.Breece Hall

359 · #75#57 · 411
Open the evidence →
Javonte WilliamsKyren Williams
Current Superflex gap // 4

Javonte Williamsvs.Kyren Williams

436 · #52#49 · 440
Open the evidence →
Derrick HenrySaquon Barkley
Current Superflex gap // 30

Derrick Henryvs.Saquon Barkley

337 · #81#88 · 307
Open the evidence →
Derrick HenryChristian McCaffrey
Current Superflex gap // 154

Derrick Henryvs.Christian McCaffrey

337 · #81#38 · 491
Open the evidence →
Cam SkatteboBucky Irving
Current Superflex gap // 200

Cam Skattebovs.Bucky Irving

311 · #87#35 · 511
Open the evidence →
Bucky IrvingTravis Etienne
Current Superflex gap // 253

Bucky Irvingvs.Travis Etienne

511 · #35#110 · 258
Open the evidence →
Travis EtienneTreVeyon Henderson
Current Superflex gap // 5

Travis Etiennevs.TreVeyon Henderson

258 · #110#105 · 263
Open the evidence →
D'Andre SwiftJosh Jacobs
Current Superflex gap // 141

D'Andre Swiftvs.Josh Jacobs

400 · #60#107 · 259
Open the evidence →
RJ HarveyBhayshul Tuten
Current Superflex gap // 243

RJ Harveyvs.Bhayshul Tuten

230 · #125#42 · 473
Open the evidence →
Ashton JeantyBijan Robinson
Current Superflex gap // 406

Ashton Jeantyvs.Bijan Robinson

510 · #36#4 · 916
Open the evidence →
Jahmyr GibbsAshton Jeanty
Current Superflex gap // 475

Jahmyr Gibbsvs.Ashton Jeanty

985 · #2#36 · 510
Open the evidence →
Chase BrownKenneth Walker
Current Superflex gap // 329

Chase Brownvs.Kenneth Walker

372 · #72#12 · 701
Open the evidence →
Aaron JonesBraelon Allen
Current Superflex gap // 138

Aaron Jonesvs.Braelon Allen

168 · #195#90 · 306
Open the evidence →
Blake CorumJaylen Warren
Current Superflex gap // 75

Blake Corumvs.Jaylen Warren

318 · #86#62 · 393
Open the evidence →
Bucky IrvingJavonte Williams
Current Superflex gap // 75

Bucky Irvingvs.Javonte Williams

511 · #35#52 · 436
Open the evidence →

WR comparisons

33 matchups
Ja'Marr ChaseJaxon Smith-Njigba
Current Superflex gap // 118

Ja'Marr Chasevs.Jaxon Smith-Njigba

861 · #5#3 · 979
Open the evidence →
Puka NacuaAmon-Ra St. Brown
Current Superflex gap // 32

Puka Nacuavs.Amon-Ra St. Brown

738 · #8#11 · 706
Open the evidence →
Justin JeffersonMalik Nabers
Current Superflex gap // 63

Justin Jeffersonvs.Malik Nabers

632 · #17#14 · 695
Open the evidence →
CeeDee LambDrake London
Current Superflex gap // 140

CeeDee Lambvs.Drake London

696 · #13#24 · 556
Open the evidence →
Tetairoa McMillanEmeka Egbuka
Current Superflex gap // 125

Tetairoa McMillanvs.Emeka Egbuka

528 · #30#58 · 403
Open the evidence →
George PickensChris Olave
Current Superflex gap // 96

George Pickensvs.Chris Olave

448 · #47#26 · 544
Open the evidence →
Nico CollinsGarrett Wilson
Current Superflex gap // 6

Nico Collinsvs.Garrett Wilson

467 · #44#43 · 473
Open the evidence →
Ladd McConkeyDeVonta Smith
Current Superflex gap // 44

Ladd McConkeyvs.DeVonta Smith

328 · #83#71 · 372
Open the evidence →
Davante AdamsMike Evans
Current Superflex gap // 5

Davante Adamsvs.Mike Evans

253 · #113#117 · 248
Open the evidence →
Courtland SuttonStefon Diggs
Current Superflex gap // 27

Courtland Suttonvs.Stefon Diggs

164 · #198#164 · 191
Open the evidence →
Deebo SamuelStefon Diggs
Current Superflex gap // 12

Deebo Samuelvs.Stefon Diggs

179 · #183#164 · 191
Open the evidence →
Rashee RiceZay Flowers
Current Superflex gap // 172

Rashee Ricevs.Zay Flowers

354 · #78#31 · 526
Open the evidence →
Zay FlowersLuther Burden
Current Superflex gap // 11

Zay Flowersvs.Luther Burden

526 · #31#28 · 537
Open the evidence →
A.J. BrownJaylen Waddle
Current Superflex gap // 31

A.J. Brownvs.Jaylen Waddle

290 · #93#108 · 259
Open the evidence →
Tee HigginsRome Odunze
Current Superflex gap // 154

Tee Higginsvs.Rome Odunze

517 · #33#73 · 363
Open the evidence →
Marvin Harrison JrJameson Williams
Current Superflex gap // 141

Marvin Harrison Jrvs.Jameson Williams

239 · #121#67 · 380
Open the evidence →
Brian ThomasParker Washington
Current Superflex gap // 250

Brian Thomasvs.Parker Washington

235 · #124#39 · 485
Open the evidence →
Matthew GoldenJordan Addison
Current Superflex gap // 321

Matthew Goldenvs.Jordan Addison

583 · #20#106 · 262
Open the evidence →
Alec PierceJosh Downs
Current Superflex gap // 41

Alec Piercevs.Josh Downs

237 · #122#97 · 278
Open the evidence →
Puka NacuaJustin Jefferson
Current Superflex gap // 106

Puka Nacuavs.Justin Jefferson

738 · #8#17 · 632
Open the evidence →
CeeDee LambMalik Nabers
Current Superflex gap // 1

CeeDee Lambvs.Malik Nabers

696 · #13#14 · 695
Open the evidence →
Drake LondonGeorge Pickens
Current Superflex gap // 108

Drake Londonvs.George Pickens

556 · #24#47 · 448
Open the evidence →
Nico CollinsTetairoa McMillan
Current Superflex gap // 61

Nico Collinsvs.Tetairoa McMillan

467 · #44#30 · 528
Open the evidence →
Chris OlaveEmeka Egbuka
Current Superflex gap // 141

Chris Olavevs.Emeka Egbuka

544 · #26#58 · 403
Open the evidence →
Puka NacuaJaxon Smith-Njigba
Current Superflex gap // 241

Puka Nacuavs.Jaxon Smith-Njigba

738 · #8#3 · 979
Open the evidence →
DeVonta SmithZay Flowers
Current Superflex gap // 154

DeVonta Smithvs.Zay Flowers

372 · #71#31 · 526
Open the evidence →
Jaylen WaddleTee Higgins
Current Superflex gap // 258

Jaylen Waddlevs.Tee Higgins

259 · #108#33 · 517
Open the evidence →
Parker WashingtonJameson Williams
Current Superflex gap // 105

Parker Washingtonvs.Jameson Williams

485 · #39#67 · 380
Open the evidence →
Adonai MitchellMalik Washington
Current Superflex gap // 16

Adonai Mitchellvs.Malik Washington

221 · #132#145 · 205
Open the evidence →
Deebo SamuelTre Tucker
Current Superflex gap // 32

Deebo Samuelvs.Tre Tucker

179 · #183#136 · 211
Open the evidence →
Nico CollinsChris Olave
Current Superflex gap // 77

Nico Collinsvs.Chris Olave

467 · #44#26 · 544
Open the evidence →
Ladd McConkeyEmeka Egbuka
Current Superflex gap // 75

Ladd McConkeyvs.Emeka Egbuka

328 · #83#58 · 403
Open the evidence →
Rome OdunzeMarvin Harrison Jr
Current Superflex gap // 124

Rome Odunzevs.Marvin Harrison Jr

363 · #73#121 · 239
Open the evidence →

TE comparisons

14 matchups
Brock BowersTrey McBride
Current Superflex gap // 105

Brock Bowersvs.Trey McBride

792 · #6#15 · 687
Open the evidence →
Colston LovelandTyler Warren
Current Superflex gap // 46

Colston Lovelandvs.Tyler Warren

482 · #40#51 · 436
Open the evidence →
Tucker KraftHarold Fannin
Current Superflex gap // 20

Tucker Kraftvs.Harold Fannin

375 · #69#61 · 395
Open the evidence →
Sam LaPortaKyle Pitts
Current Superflex gap // 132

Sam LaPortavs.Kyle Pitts

377 · #68#118 · 245
Open the evidence →
Dalton KincaidGeorge Kittle
Current Superflex gap // 62

Dalton Kincaidvs.George Kittle

274 · #99#82 · 336
Open the evidence →
Isaiah LikelyKyle Pitts
Current Superflex gap // 144

Isaiah Likelyvs.Kyle Pitts

389 · #65#118 · 245
Open the evidence →
Chig OkonkwoMichael Mayer
Current Superflex gap // 10

Chig Okonkwovs.Michael Mayer

190 · #165#152 · 200
Open the evidence →
George KittleSam LaPorta
Current Superflex gap // 41

George Kittlevs.Sam LaPorta

336 · #82#68 · 377
Open the evidence →
Dalton KincaidKyle Pitts
Current Superflex gap // 29

Dalton Kincaidvs.Kyle Pitts

274 · #99#118 · 245
Open the evidence →
Tyler WarrenSam LaPorta
Current Superflex gap // 59

Tyler Warrenvs.Sam LaPorta

436 · #51#68 · 377
Open the evidence →
Sam LaPortaHarold Fannin
Current Superflex gap // 18

Sam LaPortavs.Harold Fannin

377 · #68#61 · 395
Open the evidence →
Tucker KraftKyle Pitts
Current Superflex gap // 130

Tucker Kraftvs.Kyle Pitts

375 · #69#118 · 245
Open the evidence →
Dallas GoedertJuwan Johnson
Current Superflex gap // 1

Dallas Goedertvs.Juwan Johnson

182 · #178#181 · 181
Open the evidence →
Tucker KraftSam LaPorta
Current Superflex gap // 2

Tucker Kraftvs.Sam LaPorta

375 · #69#68 · 377
Open the evidence →
How to read a close result

A tier is an answer.

If the value gap is less than roughly five percent and stays small across formats, the evidence does not support demanding a large add. Choose for roster need, timeline, and your own risk tolerance. The calculator remains useful for balancing a full package.

Audit the model →
Plain-language answers

Comparison FAQ

How should I compare two dynasty players?

Start with the dynasty market that matches your quarterback format, compare the value gap as a percentage rather than rank alone, and then check the scoring-specific table. A small gap means the players are trade peers; it does not create a precise required add.

Can PPR scoring change which player is worth more?

Yes. Fantasy Trade Target recalculates each player from an observed per-game scoring profile and compares the change with same-position replacement. That can widen, narrow, or occasionally reverse a baseline value gap.

Do six-point passing touchdowns change every quarterback equally?

No. The model uses each quarterback’s observed passing touchdown rate and subtracts the change for a replacement-level quarterback. It does not apply the same blanket multiplier to every QB.

Does the higher-ranked player always win the comparison?

No. The higher current market value is the baseline answer, but 1QB scarcity, redraft horizon, reception scoring, and tight end premium can change the gap. Roster construction and risk preference still sit outside the model.