Start with comparable evidence.
Both players use the same release, format, league size, and composite scale. Rank is context, while the percentage gap measures the trade difference.
24 live decisions // updated August 13, 2026
Player vs. player,with the settings on.
Compare 48 distinct players across dynasty Superflex, dynasty 1QB, tight end premium, and redraft—then measure the exact effect of standard, half-PPR, full-PPR, or six-point passing touchdowns. Every answer updates from the same validated market release.
Change the scoring, not the story.
The scoring model uses observed per-game profiles and subtracts same-position replacement. Players do not receive generic PPR or passing-TD bumps.
A market answer is not a forecast.
Injuries, lineup need, manager preference, and future outcomes remain outside the score. Close values should be treated as a tier, not false precision.
Curated head-to-head index
Twenty-four decisions worth measuring.
Matchups were selected from meaningful current value neighborhoods, not generated as every possible name combination. No player appears twice, giving the collection 48 unique evidence profiles.
QB comparisons
6 matchupsCurrent Superflex gap // 123
Josh Allenvs.Drake Maye
997 · #1#6 · 874
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 17Lamar Jacksonvs.Caleb Williams
728 · #11#10 · 745
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 13Jayden Danielsvs.Joe Burrow
720 · #13#15 · 707
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 71Justin Herbertvs.Patrick Mahomes
639 · #20#26 · 568
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 2Jalen Hurtsvs.Trevor Lawrence
556 · #31#29 · 558
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 38Bo Nixvs.Brock Purdy
528 · #35#37 · 490
Open the evidence →RB comparisons
6 matchupsCurrent Superflex gap // 3
Bijan Robinsonvs.Jahmyr Gibbs
994 · #2#3 · 991
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 91Ashton Jeantyvs.Omarion Hampton
726 · #12#21 · 635
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 55De'Von Achanevs.Jonathan Taylor
626 · #23#24 · 571
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 68James Cookvs.Kenneth Walker
558 · #30#38 · 490
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 6Christian McCaffreyvs.Chase Brown
473 · #42#41 · 479
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 1Breece Hallvs.Saquon Barkley
441 · #54#55 · 440
Open the evidence →WR comparisons
8 matchupsCurrent Superflex gap // 89
Ja'Marr Chasevs.Jaxon Smith-Njigba
984 · #4#5 · 895
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 90Puka Nacuavs.Amon-Ra St. Brown
848 · #7#9 · 758
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 15Justin Jeffersonvs.Malik Nabers
710 · #14#17 · 695
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 39CeeDee Lambvs.Drake London
672 · #19#22 · 633
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 7Tetairoa McMillanvs.Emeka Egbuka
559 · #28#32 · 552
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 52George Pickensvs.Chris Olave
539 · #33#39 · 487
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 11Nico Collinsvs.Garrett Wilson
483 · #40#44 · 472
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 4Ladd McConkeyvs.DeVonta Smith
469 · #45#46 · 465
Open the evidence →TE comparisons
4 matchupsCurrent Superflex gap // 91
Brock Bowersvs.Trey McBride
779 · #8#18 · 688
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 35Colston Lovelandvs.Tyler Warren
570 · #25#34 · 535
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 19Tucker Kraftvs.Harold Fannin
412 · #60#70 · 393
Open the evidence →Current Superflex gap // 14Sam LaPortavs.Kyle Pitts
382 · #74#78 · 368
Open the evidence →How to read a close result
A tier is an answer.
If the value gap is less than roughly five percent and stays small across formats, the evidence does not support demanding a large add. Choose for roster need, timeline, and your own risk tolerance. The calculator remains useful for balancing a full package.
Audit the model →Plain-language answers
Comparison FAQ
How should I compare two dynasty players?
Start with the dynasty market that matches your quarterback format, compare the value gap as a percentage rather than rank alone, and then check the scoring-specific table. A small gap means the players are trade peers; it does not create a precise required add.
Can PPR scoring change which player is worth more?
Yes. Fantasy Trade Target recalculates each player from an observed per-game scoring profile and compares the change with same-position replacement. That can widen, narrow, or occasionally reverse a baseline value gap.
Do six-point passing touchdowns change every quarterback equally?
No. The model uses each quarterback’s observed passing touchdown rate and subtracts the change for a replacement-level quarterback. It does not apply the same blanket multiplier to every QB.
Does the higher-ranked player always win the comparison?
No. The higher current market value is the baseline answer, but 1QB scarcity, redraft horizon, reception scoring, and tight end premium can change the gap. Roster construction and risk preference still sit outside the model.