Free. No login. No nonsense.
Head-to-head // QBRelease ftt-20261113T130523Z

Justin Herbert or Patrick Mahomes: who has more dynasty value?

The short answer

Patrick Mahomes is currently worth more than Justin Herbert in dynasty Superflex: 546 versus 401, a 26.6% gap.

Name recognition can obscure the current price. This matchup keeps the decision anchored to today’s composite values, replacement-relative passing-TD adjustment, and the different scarcity of one- and two-quarterback leagues.

Latest usage // through Week 10

What changed on the field?

Recent workload and listed availability add context to the market price. They describe what happened; they do not predict the next game.

Week 10 · vs. BAL

Justin Herbert

PPR points
16.3
Latest game
Attempts + carries
25
+1 from the prior recorded week
Snap share
100%
Latest game

Listed availability: Active.

See the Week 10 QB usage report →
Week 10 · vs. ATL

Patrick Mahomes

PPR points
35.4
Latest game
Attempts + carries
37
+4 from the prior recorded week
Snap share
95%
Latest game

Listed availability: Week 11: Full · Elbow.

See the Week 10 QB usage report →
Same players // four markets

What changes in Superflex, 1QB, TEP, and redraft?

These rows change one major market context at a time. Hover or focus the dotted labels for a plain-language definition. Values share one 0–1,000 composite scale.

League settingJustin HerbertPatrick MahomesCurrent answer
Dynasty Superflex ⓘTwo QB-eligible starting slots; 4-point passing TDs and Standard scoring.401546Patrick Mahomes +145
Dynasty 1QB ⓘOne starting quarterback; 4-point passing TDs and Standard scoring.299403Patrick Mahomes +104
Superflex TEP ⓘSuperflex with an additional tight end reception premium.401546Patrick Mahomes +145
Redraft 1QB ⓘCurrent-season value only; one quarterback and Standard scoring.19163Patrick Mahomes +144

Format verdict // The same player leads all four markets, but the gap ranges from 104 to 145 points. Format still changes the price.

Passing TD scoring // player-level

Does 4-point vs. 6-point passing TD scoring change it?

The added passing-TD points are calculated from each player’s observed rate, then measured against a replacement quarterback. It is not a generic multiplier.

League settingJustin HerbertPatrick MahomesCurrent answer
4-point passing TD ⓘEach passing touchdown scores four points; Standard scoring remains on.401546Patrick Mahomes +145
6-point passing TD ⓘEach passing touchdown scores six points; Standard scoring remains on.403550Patrick Mahomes +147
Scoring verdict: No leader flip appears in the displayed scoring settings. The gap ranges from 145 to 147 value points, so scoring can still change the price.
Observed production // 2025

The evidence underneath the market answer.

These are descriptive season results, not projections. Missing upstream fields remain visibly unavailable instead of being guessed.

Justin Herbert

QB19
Fantasy points/game
18.7
Consistency grade
B
Pass yards/game
232.9
Pass TD/game
1.6
Rush yards/game
31.1
Completion rate
66.4%

Patrick Mahomes

QB10
Fantasy points/game
17.5
Consistency grade
B
Pass yards/game
211
Pass TD/game
1.3
Rush yards/game
24.8
Completion rate
62.7%
Decision rule

Start with Patrick Mahomes's edge.

Price the current market difference first; use personal conviction only after the calculator shows what the name premium costs.

Not at the baseline price. Patrick Mahomes holds the larger current value, so a straight swap gives up a 26.6% market edge before roster fit is considered. Recent usage and listed availability provide context, but starting-lineup need and manager-specific preference remain outside the model.

Direct answers

Comparison FAQ

Who is worth more in dynasty: Justin Herbert or Patrick Mahomes?

Patrick Mahomes is currently worth more than Justin Herbert in dynasty Superflex: 546 versus 401, a 26.6% gap.

Should I trade Justin Herbert for Patrick Mahomes straight up?

Not at the baseline price. Patrick Mahomes holds the larger current value, so a straight swap gives up a 26.6% market edge before roster fit is considered.

Does scoring change the Justin Herbert vs. Patrick Mahomes comparison?

No leader flip appears in the displayed scoring settings. The gap ranges from 145 to 147 value points, so scoring can still change the price.

Why do Superflex and 1QB values differ?

Superflex makes starting quarterbacks scarcer, while 1QB pushes replacement closer to the starters. The displayed format gap ranges from 104 to 145 value points.

Same-position decisions

Compare the rest of the tier.

Next decision

Put both players in the full package.