Free. No login. No nonsense.
FANTASY TRADETARGET
Week 5 lineup decision · updated Oct 7, 2026, 3:25 PM EDT

Amon-Ra St. Brown or James Cook: who should I start?

Amon-Ra St. Brown has the narrow Week 5 lean over James Cook. The Half PPR projection is 17.2 to 16.3.

The lean blends recorded scoring, recent workload, opponent positional defense and only same-week listed availability. Recheck the official inactive list before kickoff.

Start lean
Photograph of Amon-Ra St. Brown

Amon-Ra St. Brown

DET vs. ARI
Floor9.4
Median17.2
Ceiling19.7

Recent PPG: 19.0

Recent volume: 9.5

Snap share: 85%

Availability: No current-week designation

Open player file →
Photograph of James Cook

James Cook

BUF vs. LAR
Floor8.7
Median16.3
Ceiling20.5

Recent PPG: 15.9

Recent volume: 19.5

Snap share: 63%

Availability: No current-week designation

Open player file →
Scoring changes the call

Week 5 projection by format.

4 points per passing TD
Standard

Start James Cook

1.8-point gapHigh confidence
Other option

Amon-Ra St. Brown

DET vs. ARI
Floor
6.2
Projection
13.6
Ceiling
15.0
Recommended start

James Cook

BUF vs. LAR
Floor
8.5
Projection
15.4
Ceiling
19.5
Half PPR

Start Amon-Ra St. Brown — close call

0.9-point gapHigh confidence
Recommended start

Amon-Ra St. Brown

DET vs. ARI
Floor
9.4
Projection
17.2
Ceiling
19.7
Other option

James Cook

BUF vs. LAR
Floor
8.7
Projection
16.3
Ceiling
20.5
PPR

Start Amon-Ra St. Brown

3.6-point gapHigh confidence
Recommended start

Amon-Ra St. Brown

DET vs. ARI
Floor
12.8
Projection
20.8
Ceiling
24.9
Other option

James Cook

BUF vs. LAR
Floor
10.6
Projection
17.2
Ceiling
21.4

Floor and ceiling show the lower and upper ends of the player's recent scoring range. The projection is the middle estimate after current role, matchup, and same-week availability are applied.

Why the model leans this way

Role first. Matchup second. Availability always visible.

Two viable FLEX options with similar weekly projections, compared through recent opportunity, scoring format, matchup and current availability.

Amon-Ra St. Brown: recent role lowers the estimate, and the matchup is neutral. James Cook: recent role raises the estimate, and the matchup is neutral.

Availability adjustments apply only when the source contains a Week 5 report. Older designations remain visible in the injury archive but do not reduce this projection.

Week 4 final result

James Cook scored more. The pregame lean was wrong.

Amon-Ra St. Brown: 11.5 Half PPR · James Cook: 15.3 Half PPR.

Recent usageCheck snaps and opportunities →AvailabilityOpen the injury report →Rest of seasonCompare redraft value →