Free. No login. No nonsense.
FANTASY TRADETARGET
Rest of 2026 · after Week 8 · updated Nov 5, 2026, 8:37 PM EST

Should I trade Patrick Mahomes for Tyler Shough?

Keep Patrick Mahomes over Tyler Shough in a one-for-one redraft deal.

This answer compares a straight one-for-one redraft trade for the rest of the season. League depth, lineup needs and other pieces in the offer can change the call.

Trade lean
Photograph of Patrick Mahomes

Patrick Mahomes

KC · QB · Full
Overall rank#67
FTT rating28.3
Recent PPG14.7

Recent workload: 36.3

Snap share: 100%

Schedule: Balanced

Games rated: 10

Open player file →
Photograph of Tyler Shough

Tyler Shough

NO · QB · Full
Overall rank#86
FTT rating21.1
Recent PPG14.1

Recent workload: 37.8

Snap share: 99%

Schedule: Balanced

Games rated: 10

Open player file →
Scoring-format check

Does PPR, Half PPR or Standard change the trade?

FormatPreferred sidePatrick MahomesTyler ShoughGap
PPRPatrick Mahomes#67 · 28.3#86 · 21.17.2
Half PPRPatrick Mahomes#67 · 28.3#87 · 21.17.2
StandardPatrick Mahomes#68 · 28.3#87 · 21.07.3
Why the model leans this way

Current value, role and remaining runway.

Patrick Mahomes is overall PPR rank #67 with 14.7 recent points per game, 36.3 opportunities and a balanced remaining schedule.

Tyler Shough is overall PPR rank #86 with 14.1 recent points per game, 37.8 opportunities and a balanced remaining schedule.

Current redraft value is the anchor. Recent scoring and opportunity, snap share and remaining positional schedule refine the rest-of-season order.

Full offerPrice this trade →This weekCompare the lineup call →Full boardSee ROS rankings →
Questions, answered

Should I trade Patrick Mahomes for Tyler Shough?

Keep Patrick Mahomes over Tyler Shough in a one-for-one redraft deal. The current PPR rest-of-season ratings favor Patrick Mahomes, 28.3 to 21.1.

Does scoring format change the answer?

PPR favors Patrick Mahomes, Half PPR favors Patrick Mahomes, and Standard favors Patrick Mahomes.

What if other players or picks are included?

Use the preloaded trade calculator to price every piece together. This page evaluates only the straight one-for-one swap.

Is this a dynasty or weekly start/sit answer?

Neither. This is a redraft rest-of-season trade comparison. Dynasty value and a single-week lineup decision use different time horizons.