Dynasty Superflex baseline
Tua Tagovailoa
ATL · QB33 · age 28.5
139#162 overall
Head-to-head // QBRelease ftt-20260912T025335Z
Tua Tagovailoa or Geno Smith: who has more dynasty value?
The short answer
Tua Tagovailoa and Geno Smith are in the same current dynasty Superflex tier: 139 versus 146, a 4.8% gap.
This veteran quarterback comparison starts with a narrow Superflex market gap and tests it across 1QB, redraft, and passing-touchdown scoring. The separate contexts make scarcity and immediate utility visible without turning either into a forecast.
Dynasty Superflex baseline
Geno Smith
NYJ · QB30 · age 35.9
146#152 overall
Same players // four markets
What changes in Superflex, 1QB, TEP, and redraft?
These rows change one major market context at a time. Hover or focus the dotted labels for a plain-language definition. Values share one 0–1,000 composite scale.
| League setting | Tua Tagovailoa | Geno Smith | Current answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dynasty Superflex ⓘTwo QB-eligible starting slots; 4-point passing TDs and Standard scoring. | 139 | 146 | Same tier |
| Dynasty 1QB ⓘOne starting quarterback; 4-point passing TDs and Standard scoring. | 69 | 74 | Geno Smith +5 |
| Superflex TEP ⓘSuperflex with an additional tight end reception premium. | 139 | 146 | Same tier |
| Redraft 1QB ⓘCurrent-season value only; one quarterback and Standard scoring. | 1 | 10 | Geno Smith +9 |
Format verdict // The same player leads all four markets, but the gap ranges from 5 to 9 points. Format still changes the price.
Passing TD scoring // player-level
Does 4-point vs. 6-point passing TD scoring change it?
The added passing-TD points are calculated from each player’s observed rate, then measured against a replacement quarterback. It is not a generic multiplier.
| League setting | Tua Tagovailoa | Geno Smith | Current answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4-point passing TD ⓘEach passing touchdown scores four points; Standard scoring remains on. | 139 | 146 | Same tier |
| 6-point passing TD ⓘEach passing touchdown scores six points; Standard scoring remains on. | 140 | 145 | Same tier |
Scoring verdict: No leader flip appears in the displayed scoring settings. The gap ranges from 5 to 7 value points, so scoring can still change the price.
Observed production // latest season
The evidence underneath the market answer.
These are descriptive season results, not projections. Missing upstream fields remain visibly unavailable instead of being guessed.
Tua Tagovailoa
QB33- Fantasy points/game
- Not available
- Consistency grade
- D
- Pass yards/game
- Not available
- Pass TD/game
- Not available
- Rush yards/game
- Not available
- Completion rate
- Not available
Geno Smith
QB30- Fantasy points/game
- Not available
- Consistency grade
- F
- Pass yards/game
- Not available
- Pass TD/game
- Not available
- Rush yards/game
- Not available
- Completion rate
- Not available
Decision rule
Treat the gap like a tiebreaker.
Use the six-point passing-TD and redraft rows to break a close call, but keep the offer modest when the dynasty market remains in one tier.
Yes, the current baseline supports treating Tua Tagovailoa and Geno Smith as straight-up trade peers. A manager can still prefer either side, but the model does not support a large automatic add. Injury status, starting-lineup need, and manager-specific preference are outside this model.
Direct answers
Comparison FAQ
Who is worth more in dynasty: Tua Tagovailoa or Geno Smith?
Tua Tagovailoa and Geno Smith are in the same current dynasty Superflex tier: 139 versus 146, a 4.8% gap.
Should I trade Tua Tagovailoa for Geno Smith straight up?
Yes, the current baseline supports treating Tua Tagovailoa and Geno Smith as straight-up trade peers. A manager can still prefer either side, but the model does not support a large automatic add.
Does scoring change the Tua Tagovailoa vs. Geno Smith comparison?
No leader flip appears in the displayed scoring settings. The gap ranges from 5 to 7 value points, so scoring can still change the price.
Why do Superflex and 1QB values differ?
Superflex makes starting quarterbacks scarcer, while 1QB pushes replacement closer to the starters. The displayed format gap ranges from 5 to 9 value points.
Same-position decisions